Shop By
Active Filters:
Reset Filters
Skip Left Nav
Jump to Top of List

Products by  "$2.01 - $5.00" and "Paper"

(1819 items)
Dog Party Dog Bone-Shaped Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
Dog Party Dog Bone-Shaped Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #13957212
$2.79
 
 
Quick View
1/2" Bulk 800 Pc. Multicolor Paw Prints Mini Stickers
1/2" Bulk 800 Pc. Multicolor Paw Prints Mini Stickers
8 Sheet(s) #9/1177
$4.49
(6)
 
 
Quick View
Small Rio Paper Gift Bags - 12 Pc.
Small Rio Paper Gift Bags - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13829761
Clearance
Price
$3.67
49% OFF
 
 
Quick View
Purr-Fect Birthday Party Kitten Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
Purr-Fect Birthday Party Kitten Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
16 Piece(s) #13818528
$3.99
 
 
Quick View
Farm Party Barn-Shaped Paper Dinner Plates - 8 Ct.
Farm Party Barn-Shaped Paper Dinner Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #13968764
$4.49
 
 
Quick View
5" Bulk 50 Ct. Green Disposable Paper Beverage Napkins
5" Bulk 50 Ct. Green Disposable Paper Beverage Napkins
50 Piece(s) #70/1059
$2.99
(82)
 
 
Quick View
4 3/4" x 6 1/2" The Polar Express™ Believe Sticker Puzzles - 12 Pc.
4 3/4" x 6 1/2" The Polar Express™ Believe Sticker Puzzles - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #14465106
Clearance
Price
$3.78
36% OFF
 
 
Quick View
Fairy Floral & Gold Foil Butterfies Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
Fairy Floral & Gold Foil Butterfies Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
16 Piece(s) #13943042
$3.29
(2)
 
 
Quick View
Disney's Winnie the Pooh Party Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
Disney's Winnie the Pooh Party Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #13958740
$3.49
(2)
 
 
Quick View
81 ft. Apple Green Crepe Paper Streamer Party Decoration
81 ft. Apple Green Crepe Paper Streamer Party Decoration
81 ft #70/1812
On
Sale
$2.88
12% OFF
(13)
 
 
Quick View
Gold Foil Nativity Christ Is Born Paper Dinner Plates - 8 Ct.
Gold Foil Nativity Christ Is Born Paper Dinner Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Unit(s) #14148460
On
Sale
$2.98
9% OFF
 
 
Quick View
6 1/2" Celestial Party Disposable Paper Luncheon Napkins - 16 Ct.
6 1/2" Celestial Party Disposable Paper Luncheon Napkins - 16 Ct.
16 Piece(s) #14434496
$3.29
 
 
Quick View
Red Metallic Polka Dot Luncheon Napkins - 32 Pc.
Red Metallic Polka Dot Luncheon Napkins - 32 Pc.
32 Piece(s) #13846356
On
Sale
$2.37
20% OFF
(5)
 
 
Quick View
Palm Leaf Beverage Napkins - 16 Pc.
Palm Leaf Beverage Napkins - 16 Pc.
16 Piece(s) #13971892
$2.79
 
 
Quick View
Lettuce Celebrate Taco Party Dinner Paper Plates - 8 Ct.
Lettuce Celebrate Taco Party Dinner Paper Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #13962142
$2.99
 
 
Quick View
Baby Shark Cone Party Hats - 8 Pc.
Baby Shark Cone Party Hats - 8 Pc.
8 Piece(s) #13947372
$4.49
(4)
 
 
Quick View
Radical 80s Party Arcade Game Square Paper Dinner Plates - 8 Ct.
Radical 80s Party Arcade Game Square Paper Dinner Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #13648606
$2.99
(4)
 
 
Quick View
Spa Party Paper Dinner Plates - 8 Ct.
Spa Party Paper Dinner Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #14393225
$2.99
 
 
Quick View
50th Birthday Party Vintage Dude Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
50th Birthday Party Vintage Dude Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #13774009
$3.99
(5)
 
 
Quick View
Bulk 50 Pc. God Gave Me You Cupcake Picks
Bulk 50 Pc. God Gave Me You Cupcake Picks
50 Piece(s) #13829325
Clearance
Price
$2.37
46% OFF
(3)
 
 
Quick View
Space Party Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
Space Party Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
16 Piece(s) #13773182
$3.29
(5)
 
 
Quick View
2" x 6" Bulk 48 Pc. 2025 Everyday Calendar Cardstock Bookmarks
2" x 6" Bulk 48 Pc. 2025 Everyday Calendar Cardstock Bookmarks
48 Piece(s) #14465190
Clearance
Price
$3.97
49% OFF
 
 
Quick View
Colorful Fiesta Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Pc.
Colorful Fiesta Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Pc.
8 Piece(s) #14209331
$2.79
 
 
Quick View
Oh Happy Day Stickers
Oh Happy Day Stickers
6 Sheet(s) #13980986
$4.99
 
 
Quick View
Mickey Mouse Beverage Napkins - 16 Pc.
Mickey Mouse Beverage Napkins - 16 Pc.
16 Count #14122853
$3.29
 
 
Quick View
9 1/2" White Heart-Shaped Folding Paper Hand Fans - 12 Pc.
9 1/2" White Heart-Shaped Folding Paper Hand Fans - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13958949
$4.99
(11)
 
 
Quick View
9" Sonic the Hedgehog™ Party Disposable Paper Dinner Plates - 8 Ct.
9" Sonic the Hedgehog™ Party Disposable Paper Dinner Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #14478666
$4.29
 
 
Quick View
Pink & Blue Watercolor Beverage Napkins
Pink & Blue Watercolor Beverage Napkins
16 Piece(s) #13837181
$2.79
 
 
Quick View
Batman™ Sticker Sheets - 4 Pc.
Batman™ Sticker Sheets - 4 Pc.
4 Piece(s) #14122569
$2.49
 
 
Quick View
Red Patterned Tin Tie Treat Bags with Window - 12 Pc.
Red Patterned Tin Tie Treat Bags with Window - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13940861
Clearance
Price
$3.27
61% OFF
(2)
 
 
Quick View
3 1/2" 9 oz. Hello Kitty & Friends Party Disposable Paper Cups – 8 Ct.
3 1/2" 9 oz. Hello Kitty & Friends Party Disposable Paper Cups – 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #14371913
$3.79
 
 
Quick View
5" x 10" Green Treat Bags - 12 Pc.
5" x 10" Green Treat Bags - 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #3/175
On
Sale
$4.98
28% OFF
(73)
 
 
Quick View
Orange Plaid Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
Orange Plaid Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #13982639
$2.19
 
 
Quick View
Little Fisherman Gone Fishin’ Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
Little Fisherman Gone Fishin’ Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #13733939
$2.79
(5)
 
 
Quick View
Lemon Party Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
Lemon Party Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #14232491
$2.79
 
 
Quick View
Iridescent Fairy Scalloped Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
Iridescent Fairy Scalloped Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #13943043
$2.99
 
 
Quick View
Vintage Dude Birthday Beverage Napkins - 16 Pc.
Vintage Dude Birthday Beverage Napkins - 16 Pc.
16 Piece(s) #13774725
$3.29
(5)
 
 
Quick View
DC Comics Justice League™ Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
DC Comics Justice League™ Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
16 Piece(s) #13936257
$3.99
 
 
Quick View
Marvel’s Spider-Man™ Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
Marvel’s Spider-Man™ Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #14232982
$3.49
 
 
Quick View
5" Bulk 50 Ct. White Disposable Paper Beverage Napkins
5" Bulk 50 Ct. White Disposable Paper Beverage Napkins
50 Piece(s) #70/1062
$2.99
(82)
 
 
Quick View
9" Hello Kitty & Friends Party Disposable Paper Dinner Plates – 8 Ct.
9" Hello Kitty & Friends Party Disposable Paper Dinner Plates – 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #14371909
$4.29
 
 
Quick View
Disney® The Little Mermaid™ Cone Party Hats - 8 Pc.
Disney® The Little Mermaid™ Cone Party Hats - 8 Pc.
8 Piece(s) #13936391
$4.69
 
 
Quick View
3" - 5 3/4" Graduation Sayings Cardstock Photo Stick Props- 12 Pc.
3" - 5 3/4" Graduation Sayings Cardstock Photo Stick Props- 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13830886
Clearance
Price
$3.97
60% OFF
 
 
Quick View
Movie Party Dinner Napkins - 16 Pc.
Movie Party Dinner Napkins - 16 Pc.
16 Piece(s) #13795128
$3.29
(2)
 
 
Quick View
Disney’s Toy Story 4™ Ducky & Bunny Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
Disney’s Toy Story 4™ Ducky & Bunny Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
16 Piece(s) #13936352
$3.99
 
 
Quick View
Baseball Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
Baseball Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #14115315
$3.49
 
 
Quick View
7" Slate Blue Round Disposable Paper Dessert Plates - 24 Ct.
7" Slate Blue Round Disposable Paper Dessert Plates - 24 Ct.
24 Piece(s) #14393210
$3.99
(81)
 
 
Quick View
5" Pastel Butterfly Disposable Paper Beverage Napkins - 16 Ct.
5" Pastel Butterfly Disposable Paper Beverage Napkins - 16 Ct.
16 Piece(s) #14521848
$2.79
 
 
Quick View
5" Airplane Party Paper Beverage Napkins - 16 Ct.
5" Airplane Party Paper Beverage Napkins - 16 Ct.
16 Piece(s) #14521896
$2.79
 
 
Quick View
Karate Party Paper Dinner Plates - 8 Ct.
Karate Party Paper Dinner Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #14091957
$4.49
 
 
Quick View
9" Candy World Round Disposable Paper Dinner Plates - 8 Ct.
9" Candy World Round Disposable Paper Dinner Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #13971798
$2.99
 
 
Quick View
1 1/2" Realistic Dog Photo Paper Sticker Roll – 100 Pc.
1 1/2" Realistic Dog Photo Paper Sticker Roll – 100 Pc.
1 Roll(s) #9/1483
$4.49
(26)
 
 
Quick View
Puppy Party Photo Stick Props- 12 Pc.
Puppy Party Photo Stick Props- 12 Pc.
Per Dozen #13721384
Clearance
Price
$2.87
68% OFF
(13)
 
 
Quick View
6 1/2" Watercolor Floral Disposable Paper Luncheon Napkins - 16 Ct.
6 1/2" Watercolor Floral Disposable Paper Luncheon Napkins - 16 Ct.
16 Piece(s) #14522042
$3.29
 
 
Quick View
Disney's Encanto Beverage Napkins- 16 Pc.
Disney's Encanto Beverage Napkins- 16 Pc.
16 Piece(s) #14122929
$2.39
 
 
Quick View
5" Bulk 50 Ct. Orange Disposable Paper Beverage Napkins
5" Bulk 50 Ct. Orange Disposable Paper Beverage Napkins
50 Piece(s) #70/1056
$2.99
(82)
 
 
Quick View
Bumblebee Party Beverage Napkins - 16 Pc.
Bumblebee Party Beverage Napkins - 16 Pc.
16 Piece(s) #13911612
$3.29
(3)
 
 
Quick View
Construction Zone Beverage Napkins - 16 Pc.
Construction Zone Beverage Napkins - 16 Pc.
16 Piece(s) #13677440
$2.79
(10)
 
 
Quick View
Perfectly Paris Eifel Tower Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
Perfectly Paris Eifel Tower Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
16 Piece(s) #13677604
$3.29
(6)
 
 
Quick View
6 1/2" Bright Dino Party Triceratops Paper Luncheon Napkins - 16 Ct.
6 1/2" Bright Dino Party Triceratops Paper Luncheon Napkins - 16 Ct.
16 Piece(s) #14393168
$3.29
 
 
Quick View
Mother’s Day Floral World's Best Mom Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
Mother’s Day Floral World's Best Mom Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
16 Piece(s) #13937433
$3.79
 
 
Quick View
Little Artist Party Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
Little Artist Party Luncheon Napkins - 16 Pc.
16 Piece(s) #13755398
$3.29
 
 
Quick View
Cheers & Beers Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
Cheers & Beers Paper Dessert Plates - 8 Ct.
8 Piece(s) #13901954
$2.19
 
 
Quick View
Hockey Beverage Napkins - 16 Pc.
Hockey Beverage Napkins - 16 Pc.
16 Piece(s) #14151666
$2.79
 
 
Quick View
1 ... 9 10 11 ... 29